
What Is a Good Deductible Amount for Car Insurance
A good deductible is the highest amount you could pay out of pocket today without it hurting, not the lowest one offered to you.
Free to compare

What actually decides a good deductible for you
- Your emergency savings Your deductible should be money you already have set aside, not money you'd need to borrow. If a repair bill would force you onto a credit card, the deductible is too high for you right now.
- How often you'd actually claim A low deductible only helps if you'd actually file a claim for a small fender bender. If you'd pay minor damage yourself anyway to avoid a rate increase, a higher deductible costs you nothing extra.
- The age and value of the car An older car worth little isn't worth insuring the same way as a new one. Check what the car is worth before deciding how much deductible makes sense for it.
- Deductibles by coverage type Collision and comprehensive usually carry their own deductibles, and they don't have to match. Set each one based on how likely that type of damage is for your situation.
- How the premium responds Raising a deductible doesn't always lower the premium by much, and the effect varies by insurer. Get quotes at two or three deductible levels before assuming a higher one is worth it.

A driver with an older car and a tight budget
A driver had kept the same deductible for years because that's what the policy started with when the car was new. The car was now eight years old and worth much less, and the driver had built up enough savings to cover a bigger repair bill without trouble. The low deductible was quietly costing more every renewal than it was likely ever to save.
The driver checked the car's current value, confirmed the savings could cover a higher amount without strain, and asked for quotes at a couple of higher deductible levels for comparison. The difference in premium was enough to matter over a year, and the driver still had enough saved to cover the new deductible twice over if needed. The driver raised it, kept the change in mind for when the car was eventually replaced, and moved on.
Should my deductible be the same for collision and comprehensive?
Not necessarily. These are two different risks, and they don't have to be treated the same way just because they sit on the same policy.
Comprehensive covers things like weather, theft, and animals, which are often less predictable and sometimes cheaper to repair than a full collision claim. Some drivers keep a lower comprehensive deductible because those claims tend to be smaller and less frequent, while raising the collision deductible where the premium impact is usually bigger. Check how your insurer prices each one separately before assuming they should match, since the right split depends on your own driving and the car itself.
Once you know the deductible that fits your savings and car, compare quotes at that level to see what it costs.

Choosing a higher deductible to lower your premium
If you do
Your premium drops at each renewal, sometimes meaningfully. If something happens to the car, you pay more upfront before coverage kicks in, so you need that amount sitting in savings and ready, not hypothetical.
If you don't
You keep paying a higher premium for a lower deductible you may rarely use. If you'd never actually file a claim for smaller damage anyway, that extra premium is buying you protection you're unlikely to use.
Is a high deductible too high for an old car?
It depends on the car's value, not a fixed rule. If the car is worth only a little more than the deductible, you may be close to paying for the whole repair yourself anyway, which is worth knowing before you set it. Check the car's current value and weigh it against your savings before deciding, and reconsider the deductible whenever the car's value changes significantly.
Can I change my deductible mid-policy?
Usually yes, but it depends on your insurer's rules and may only take effect at renewal or require a new policy term. Call and ask directly rather than assuming, since some insurers allow a mid-term change and others don't. If a change isn't allowed right away, mark your renewal date so you remember to revisit it.
Does a higher deductible affect my ability to get repairs approved?
No, the deductible doesn't change what repairs are approved, only how much you pay before coverage starts. The insurer still evaluates the claim and the repair the same way regardless of deductible amount. What changes is your out-of-pocket cost, so check that figure against your savings rather than worrying about approval.



