
What Should My Personal Liability Limit Be
Your liability limit should cover what you have, not just what the state requires you to carry.
Free to compare

Choosing a limit after a close call
A reader owned a home, had some savings, and was driving the state minimum liability limit because that's what the car came with when they bought it used. A friend pointed out that a bad accident, even one that was clearly their fault by a moment of distraction, could cost far more than that minimum covers in medical bills and lost income for the other driver. They sat down and added up what they owned: the home equity, the savings account, a small investment account. The number was uncomfortable to look at next to their coverage.
They raised their liability limit to match roughly what they had to protect, and looked into an umbrella policy on top of it since their assets had grown past what standard auto limits alone could shield. The extra cost per month was small compared to what a lawsuit could take. They also told their insurer about the change so it was reflected clearly on the policy, rather than discovering a gap later. The peace of mind, they said, was worth more than the discount they gave up by not carrying the bare minimum anymore.

The short version
Your liability limit should be high enough to cover what you own and a reasonable share of future earnings, because a judgment against you can reach both. Add up your assets, check if your state allows wage garnishment for judgments, and raise your limit to match, considering an umbrella policy if you have significant assets.
What happens if a judgment is bigger than my liability limit?
If a court awards more than your policy covers, you are personally responsible for the difference. That can mean a judgment against your savings, your home equity, future wages, or other assets, depending on your state's rules for collecting on judgments.
This is exactly why the limit matters so much. Insurance pays up to its limit and then stops, regardless of what you actually owe. Anything above that line is yours to pay, often over years, until the debt is satisfied. People with more to lose from a judgment, more savings, more equity, more income, need higher limits or an umbrella policy specifically to close that gap before it ever opens.
Compare quotes at the liability limit that actually matches what you have to protect.

How to land on the right number
- Add up your assets List your savings, home equity, and investments, since all of it can be at risk in a lawsuit. This total is your starting point for a limit.
- Check your state's rules Some states allow wage garnishment or liens for unpaid judgments and some limit it. Look up your state's rules so you know what's actually exposed.
- Think about future earnings A judgment can follow you for years if you're young or early in your career. Factor in what you expect to earn, not just what you have now.
- Consider an umbrella policy If your assets are substantial, raising auto liability alone may not be enough. Ask about an umbrella policy that extends coverage well beyond standard auto limits.
- Match limits across policies Your auto and home or renters liability limits should work together, not leave gaps. Check that an umbrella policy, if you get one, requires a minimum underlying limit on both.
Why the limit has to match what you own
Liability coverage exists to pay for harm you cause to other people, their property, or their ability to earn a living, up to the limit you chose. The state minimum is a floor, not a recommendation. It was set to make sure every driver carries something, not to reflect what a serious accident actually costs. Many accidents involving injury go well past that floor.
The real exposure isn't the accident itself, it's the gap between what your policy pays and what a court decides you owe. That excess doesn't disappear. It becomes a personal debt, and depending on your state, it can be collected from savings, home equity, or even future paychecks through garnishment. The more you have and the more you expect to earn, the more there is for a judgment to reach, which is why the right limit depends on your situation rather than a single standard number.
This is also why people with few assets sometimes stay closer to the minimum while people with a home, retirement savings, or a growing income raise their limits substantially or add an umbrella policy. An umbrella policy sits on top of your auto and home liability limits and extends them further, usually at a lower cost per dollar of coverage than raising your auto limit alone. Insurers typically require you to carry a minimum liability limit on the underlying auto policy before they'll issue one.
There's no universal right answer because everyone's exposure is different. The honest approach is to look at what you'd lose in a worst case lawsuit and choose a limit, or a limit plus umbrella policy, that actually closes that gap.
Does raising my liability limit cost a lot more per month?
Usually not much, because liability coverage is often one of the cheaper parts of a policy to increase in steps. The jump from a low limit to a much higher one is typically smaller than people expect, especially compared to the cost of other coverages like collision. Ask your insurer for a side by side quote at a few different limits before deciding, since the actual difference varies by insurer and by your driving history.
Do I need an umbrella policy if I already have high auto liability limits?
It depends on how much you have to protect beyond what your auto limit already covers. An umbrella policy extends liability protection past your auto and home limits, which matters most if your assets or income exceed what those standard limits alone would shield in a lawsuit. If you have significant savings, equity, or earning potential, it's worth asking an insurer what an umbrella policy would add and what underlying limits it requires.
Can my liability limit be too high for my situation?
Yes, if you're paying for protection far beyond what you actually have to lose. There's little point carrying a very high limit if your assets and future earnings are modest, since a judgment can't take more than what's realistically collectible. Review your limit again as your savings, home equity, or income change over time, since the right number for you now may not be the right number in a few years.


